August 2, 2007

Fisher-Price Recalls Toys for Lead

Seriously? We took the lead out of life like 30 years ago. Why are we suddenly sliding back into this. First lunch boxes, then Thomas the Train, and now Big Bird and Dora.

[see update at bottom. Head of Chinese company that supplied the toys committed suicide. Paint supplied by his best friend. It is so sad to see how many lives are destroyed by people who cheat just to make a few bucks.]

Fisher-Price to recall nearly 1M toys
Associated Press Writers Wed Aug 1, 9:33 PM ET

WASHINGTON - Toy-maker Fisher-Price is recalling 83 types of toys — including the popular Big Bird, Elmo, Dora and Diego characters — because their paint contains excessive amounts of lead.

The worldwide recall being announced Thursday involves 967,000 plastic preschool toys made by a Chinese vendor and sold in the United States between May and August. It is the latest in a wave of recalls that has heightened global concern about the safety of Chinese-made products.

The recall is the first for Fisher-Price Inc. and parent company Mattel Inc. involving lead paint. It is the largest for Mattel since 1998 when Fisher-Price had to yank about 10 million Power Wheels from toy stores.

In an interview with The Associated Press on Wednesday, David Allmark, general manager of Fisher-Price, said the problem was detected by an internal probe and reported to the Consumer Product Safety Commission. The recall is particularly alarming since Mattel, known for its strict quality controls, is considered a role model in the toy industry for how it operates in China.

Fisher-Price and the commission issued statements saying parents should keep suspect toys away from children and contact the company.

The commission works with companies to issue recalls when it finds consumer goods that can be harmful. Under current regulations, children's products found to have more than .06 percent lead accessible to users are subject to a recall.

Allmark says the recall was "fast-tracked," which allowed the company to quarantine two-thirds of the toys before they even made it to store shelves. In negotiating details of the recall, Fisher-Price and the government sought to withhold details from the public until Thursday to give stores time to get suspect toys off shelves and Fisher-Price time to get its recall hot line up and running. However, some news organizations prematurely posted an embargoed version of the story online.

Allmark said the recall was troubling because Fisher-Price has had a long-standing relationship with the Chinese vendor, which had applied decorative paint to the toys. Allmark said the company would use this recall as an opportunity to put even better systems in place to monitor vendors whose conduct does not meet Mattel's standards.

He added: "We are still concluding the investigation, how it happened. ... But there will be a dramatic investigation on how this happened. We will learn from this."

The recall follows another high-profile move from toy maker RC2 Corp., which in June voluntarily recalled 1.5 million wooden railroad toys and set parts from its Thomas & Friends Wooden Railway product line. The company said that the surface paint on certain toys and parts made in China between January 2005 and April 2006 contain lead, affecting 26 components and 23 retailers.

"Anytime a company brings a banned hazardous product into the U.S. marketplace, especially one intended for children, it is unacceptable," said Nancy Nord, acting chair of the Consumer Product Safety Commission. "Ensuring that Chinese-made toys are safe for U.S. consumers is one of my highest priorities and is the subject of vital talks currently in place between CPSC and the Chinese government."

Carter Keithley, president of the Toy Industries Association, praised Mattel's quick response to the problem, and suggested Mattel will use this setback as a lesson for not only the company but for the entire industry. However, he expressed concern about how the recall and other toy recalls will play out in consumers' minds in advance of the holiday season.

"We are worried about the public feeling," said Keithley, adding he observed how toy companies are embracing strict controls during a recent toy safety seminar in China. "We have thought all along that (consumers) can be confident in the products," he said. "But if companies like Mattel have this, then you have to ask how did this happen?"

Sen. Dick Durbin, D-Ill., introduced a bill last month that he contended would dramatically expand the product safety commission's ability to protect consumers. In a statement Wednesday night, Durbin also called for better safety standards for products imported from China.

"Sadly, this is the most recent in a series of disturbing recalls of children's toys. While the toys may be different, they have one thing in common — they were manufactured in China," he said. "With the current tools and resources the Consumer Product Safety Commission has, it cannot adequately protect American consumers."

Owners of a recalled toy can exchange it for a voucher for another product of the same value. To see pictures of the recalled toys, visit For more information, call Mattel's recall hot line at 800-916-4498.


China toy boss kills self after recall
By AUDRA ANG, Associated Press Writer
1 hour, 15 minutes ago

BEIJING - The head of a Chinese toy manufacturing company at the center of a huge U.S. recall has committed suicide, a state-run newspaper said Monday.

Zhang Shuhong, who co-owned Lee Der Industrial Co. Ltd., killed himself at a warehouse over the weekend, days after China announced it had temporarily banned exports by the company, the Southern Metropolis Daily said.

Lee Der made 967,000 toys recalled earlier this month by Mattel Inc. because they were made with paint found to have excessive amounts of lead. The plastic preschool toys, sold under the Fisher-Price brand in the U.S., included the popular Big Bird, Elmo, Dora and Diego characters.

It was among the largest recalls in recent months involving Chinese products, which have come under fire for globally for containing potentially dangerous high levels of chemicals and toxins.

The Southern Metropolis Daily said that a supplier, Zhang's best friend, sold Lee Der fake paint which was used in the toys.

"The boss and the company were harmed by the paint supplier, the closest friend of our boss," a manager surnamed Liu was quoted as saying.

Liu said Zhang hung himself on Saturday, according to the report. It is common for disgraced officials to commit suicide in China.

"When I got there around 5 p.m., police had already sealed off the area," Liu said.

A company official who answered the telephone at the Lee Der factory in the southern city of Foshan on Monday said he had not heard of the news. A man at Lee Der's main office in Hong Kong said the company was not accepting interviews and hung up.

According to a search on a registry of Hong Kong companies, Zhang — whose name is spelled Cheung Shu-hung in official documents — is a co-owner of Lee Der. The other owner, Chiu Kwei-tsun, did not return telephone messages left for him.

The recall by El Segundo, California-based Mattel came just two months after RC2 Corp., a New York company, recalled 1.5 million Chinese-made wooden railroad toys and set parts from its Thomas & Friends Wooden Railway product line because of lead paint.

The maker, Hansheng Wood Products Factory, was also included in the export ban announced Thursday by the General Administration for Quality Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine, one of China's quality watchdogs.

The administration also ordered both companies to evaluate and change their business practices.

Lead poisoning can cause vomiting, anemia and learning difficulties. In extreme cases, it can cause severe neurological damage and death.

The quality watchdog also said police were investigating two companies' use of "fake plastic pigment" but did not give any details. Such pigments are a type of industrial latex usually used to increase surface gloss and smoothness.

Telephones rang unanswered at the public security bureau in Foshan and at Dongxing New Energy Company, which is the paint supplier.

In its report, the Southern Metropolis Daily said Zhang, who was in his 50s, treated his 5,000-odd employees well and always paid them on time.

The morning of his suicide, he greeted workers and chatted with some of them, the newspaper said.

Chinese companies often have long supply chains, making it difficult to trace the exact origin of components, chemicals and food additives.


Bec said...

I'm really angry on this one. I am not sure I want to exchange for a toy of similar value -- I am not sure I want any of their toys!

Maybe I am being overly dramatic here, but this is to me kind of like the Thomas the Tank Engine stuff is to others. I have an older son who is nine and we never purchased new trains for Thane, so the recall was upsetting but didn't involve us directly.

This one is different. I got a Diego Duplo set and noticed Thane, whose PDD-NOS, was engaging in imaginative play with the Diego and Baby Jaguar. I kept resisting those other Diego toys because they talk, but after two months of resisting, I started buying them. I'm guilty of indulging in retail therapy, but these made my little guy so happy. Now I have $200+ of Diego toys to take away from him.

This may be the first such recall for F-P, but I just don't get why these manufacturers don't check the toys they are getting, especially with the growing reputation for products manufactured in China to have lead paint!

Laura said...

This makes me angry, too! Fortunately all of the toys we had were made pre-May 2007 (the toys recalled were all made in May, I think) but we JUST did the Thomas lead fiasco, and haven't even received our new "unleaded" stuff back. It's to the point where I just want to avoid everything made in China, but that is another challenge, and I don't need more challenges in my life! Maybe toy manufacturers should have their toys made in countries where lead paint is not used? Just an idea. I know that Chinese labor is cheap and all, but when you have to re-make all of the toys when they're lead contaminated, and deal with pissing off your loyal customers, isn't it worth it to spend a little more? Arrgh.

My boys set up an super train track layout around the room today, and I just wonder if any of the pieces have any lead on them from the Thomas trains we shipped back. Oh well. The chelation will get it, right?

Bonnie said...

This is just crazy! What has happened to the standards for our kids in this country?!

Oh Please.. said...

Its time for the American people to file a class action lawsuit against China and ALL of the manufacturers that have endangered our children.

Anonymous said...

Well you Americans can stop taking advantage on cheap labor in China for one. Just manufacture the toys in your own homeland and pay for your toys ten times over, the world doesn't have any problems with that. Mattel made a huge killing (pardon the sick humor) when they started using cheap labor.. imagine how much return on investment they have now that their fixed costs have gone down and still they charge the same amount for a product that isn't even made in America anymore.